Rate:
Share
Views: 655
Text Size:
Comments (1)

Cognitive Bias and Investing

Eleven Reasons Why What You Think Is Probably Wrong

By Steve Christ
Thursday, December 27th, 2007

As speeches go, Alan Greenspan's presentation to the American Enterprise Institute in 1996 was a long one. Called "The Challenge of Central Banking in a Democratic Society", it contained 4,335 words that only an economist could possibly sit through without getting sleepy. To say that it was a bit dry is something of an understatement.

But of all of the words that he uttered on that night over eleven years ago, two of them have managed to live on long after he finally turned over the microphone.

Buried deep within the night's lecture there were the words "irrational exuberance," a full four years before the dot-com bubble burst, costing investors $5 trillion in the process.

Those two words turned out to be much more than a mere warning that stocks were in danger of being overpriced. They also helped to turn the idea of the efficient market hypothesis right on its head.

"Rational" Investing Means Battling Cognitive Bias

A rational market? Well hardly, according to Greenspan. And on this score he couldn't have been more right. After all, cognitive bias and investing go hand in hand.

Because as we have now learned in dealing with two massive bubbles in only ten years--first in tech and then in housing--the markets are not rational at all, at least in the short run.

In short, as Greenspan implied, there is a ghost in the machine. And because of it things aren't always as they appear to be--especially when it comes to the markets.

The reason for this, of course, is simple: markets are made up of people. And of all the things that people tend to be when it comes to their investments, irrational is near the top of the list. That is what leads to losses.

Advertisement

Alternative Energy Myths Report

Jeff Siegel's Alternative Energy Myths report is currently available at no charge for his Green Chip Review members. Green Chip Review is a daily e-letter that offers market analysis in alternative and renewable energy, organic foods, green building, and all associated LOHAS segments. For a free membership to the Green Chip Review and to reserve your copy, click here.


But by understanding how and where your reasoning can go astray, you can help to build up your portfolio by simply choosing to limit your losses on far more of those "irrational" losers. Or even better, by not selling your winners too soon.

The key here, though, is in learning to recognize the cognitive biases that have handicapped your investing in the first place.

I call them my "Eleven Reasons Why What You Think Is Probably Wrong." Learning to recognize them can save you a ton of heartache, but only if you're honest with yourself.

The eleven emotional hurdles that could be killing your portfolio:

  1. The Bandwagon Effect: This is the one that causes the most pain in a bubble. It's the idea that it's okay to follow the herd because so many other people believe in it. It's irrational because it places its faith in the safety of numbers, while completely disregarding the fundamentals. Without it a bubble is impossible.
  2. Loss Aversion: People to have a strong preference for avoiding losses over acquiring gains. It's the fear that puts them on the sidelines to stay.
  3. Disposition Effect: This is the tendency for investors to lock in gains and ride out losses. It prompts the sale of shares that are rising, while it also keeps investors tied to losers far too long. It's closely tied to loss aversion, since it's the fear of loss that dominates the thinking.
  4. Outcome Bias: Judging a decision by its outcome rather than the quality of the decision at the time that it was made. This is what makes investors completely disregard a proper decision if it turns out to be a loss.
  5. Sunken Costs Effect: Treating money that has already been spent as more valuable than money that may be spent in the future. It's what helps to build up losses because the investor believes that by selling at a loss he is wasting money. That same money could be put to use elsewhere.
  6. Recency Bias: Weighting recent data more heavily than earlier experiences. It's what freezes investors, especially after a series of losses, even though there may be a much longer string of successes in the past.
  7. Anchoring: This is the tendency for people to rely too heavily on readily available information when making a decision. Investors often base their decisions on information that mat be faulty.
  8. Belief in the Law of Small Numbers: This is when investors base their conclusions on a slice of data that is too small. It's the equivalent of making mountains out of molehills and it blurs reality.
  9. Endowment Effect: People tend to value something more once they own it. As in housing, people tend to overvalue what belongs to them. Of course, this only blinds to them to the real value.
  10. Disconfirmation Bias: This makes people critical of information which contradicts their beliefs while uncritically accepting information that is in line with them. In short, it's a trap whereby people believe what they want to believe.
  11. Post Purchase Rationalization: This when investors persuade themselves through rational argument that a purchase was a good value. Of course, if a decision needs to be rationalized after the fact it is probably wrong.

Individually, of course, all of these biases are dangerous. Taken together they are the stuff that bubbles are made of. Guarding against them in the future may be the one of the best investment decisions you'll ever make.

Because Mr. Greenspan nailed it when he said that markets were irrational.

Wishing you happiness, health and wealth,

sig

Steve Christ, Editor

Wealth Daily






Rate this article:
 
     Current Rating:  
Article RatingArticle RatingArticle RatingArticle RatingArticle Rating (20 votes)

Comment on this Article


Comments:

Comment by diego torres on 2007-12-28
Congratulations on the compilation of biases. We as humans probably have a worse bias that is to avoid accepting these truths and changing the way we face them. A portfolio loss is the best bell ring to unlock wisdom.

DTM